-
People really think Astrology is scientific?
Today on the interwebs I ran across this link. It shows how key getting an education is. It’s hard to believe that 54% of people without a high school diploma actually believe Astrology is scientific? Really?
Believing in Astrology might not be the worst thing to believe in, but it does lead to magical thinking and I’m willing to bet that believers of Astrology also believe in other things that could be harmful. Whatstheharm.net is a great site that shows the harm, and dangers there are in believing in nonsensical things.
Every day on Twitter I see otherwise smart people wasting money on nonsense. Whether it’s Astrology, acupuncture, detoxification, or just buying organic food, or falling for the “all natural” fallacy. For the most part they are just wasting money, but there are some added risks, except for organic food, that’s just a waste of money. Often I want to speak up to the people wasting their money, but who am I? Why would anybody listen to me?
Maybe some day people will wise up to all the snake oil salesmen out there, but I doubt it. As long as there is snake oil to sell, there will be people buying.
-
Organic food myths
One of my biggest pet peeves is the thought that products that are “natural” or organic are better for you. I struggle with the word “natural” all the time. What does it mean? I see it on products like cheese all the time. How is any kind of cheese products “natural”? Doesn’t cheese have to be made and processed? So processed food is natural? Or does natural mean all the the chemical compounds are from living organisms? Natural is a pretty generic term used mostly for marketing, and doesn’t mean much. Anything on the planet could be natural, or not depending on your definition of natural, if you trace it back to it’s elemental form. And just the fallacy that natural is good for you is just wrong. Arsenic, mercury, poison ivy and even lightning are all natural, and defiantly not good for you.
Then there is the whole organic thing. There is little difference between organic and non-organic products. In reality, organic products probably contain more pesticides and fertilizers than non-organic products do because they have to use less efficient, organic pesticides and fertilizers. Brian Dunning’s latest InFact video explains the difference between organic and non-organic products, and he explains it way better than I can.
-
Happy April Fool’s Day
Today it occurred to me that April Fool’s Day is actually Skeptic’s Day. It’s the one day that everybody turns on their Baloney Detector, and actually think skeptically about everything. If only people did this everyday. Once the clock clicks over to April 2nd though, people will stop thinking critically again. People should really think critically everyday about everything.
I use to hate April Fool’s Day, but I kind of like it now knowing it’s really Skeptic’s Day. April Fool’s Day pranks are pretty easy to detect. The real life charlatans trying to make a buck off of the misinformed are another story. With a little practice and knowledge spotting the snake oil salesmen is pretty easy. Carl Sagan’s The Demon-Haunted World is a great start, and a must read for any critical thinker.
April Fool’s Day is also the day the James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF) gives away their “Pigasus Awards”. The Pigasus Awards—pigasus being flying pigs— are given to the worst promoters of nonsense. Here are this years “winners”:
These are this year’s “winners.”
-
The Scientist Pigasus Award goes to NASA Engineer Richard B. Hoover, who recently announced for the third time in 14 years that he had found evidence of microscopic life in meteorites. Along with the crackpot Journal of Cosmology—a now-defunct publication founded in 2009 to publish articles advancing the scientifically unsupported idea that life began before the first stars formed and was spread throughout the early universe on meteors—Hoover pitched his warmed-over ideas to Fox News, an outlet not known for their attention to facts. Predictably, Fox News ran with the story, convincing many people that NASA had discovered extraterrestrial life.
-
The Funder Pigasus Award goes to CVS/pharmacy, for their work to support the manufacturers of scam “homeopathic” medications who sell up to $870 million a year in quack remedies to U.S. consumers. Homeopathic remedies contain none of the active ingredient they claim, and homeopathy has been shown to be useless in randomized clinical trials. CVS/pharmacy sells these quack products in thousands of stores across the U.S., right alongside real medicine, with no warning to consumers. Instead of giving their customers the facts about homeopathy, CVS/pharmacy executives are cashing in themselves by offering their own store-brand of the popular homeopathic product oscillococcinum. Oscillococcinum is made by grinding up the liver of a duck, putting none of it onto tiny sugar pills—that’s right,none of it—and then advertising the plain sugar pills as an effective treatment for flu symptoms.
-
The Media Pigasus Award goes to Dr. Mehmet Oz, who has done such a disservice to his TV viewers by promoting quack medical practices that he is now the first person to win a Pigasus two years in a row. Dr. Oz is a Harvard-educated cardiac physician who, through his syndicated TV show, has promoted faith healing, "energy medicine," and other quack theories that have no scientific basis. Oz has appeared on ABC News to give legitimacy to the claims of Brazilian faith healer “John of God,” who uses old carnival tricks to take money from the seriously ill. He’s hosted Ayurvedic guru Yogi Cameron on his show to promote nonsense "tongue examination" as a way of diagnosing health problems. This year, he really went off the deep end. In March 2011, Dr. Oz endorsed "psychic" huckster and past Pigasus winner John Edward, who pretends to talk to dead people. Oz even suggested that bereaved families should visit psychic mediums to receive (faked) messages from their dead relatives as a form of grief counseling.
-
The Performer Pigasus Award—this year for “Best Comeback”—goes to televangelist Peter Popoff. Popoff made millions in the 1980s by pretending to heal the sick and receive information about audience members directly from god. He went bankrupt in 1987 after JREF founder James Randi exposed him for using a secret earpiece to receive information about audience members from his wife. Now he’s back to prey on victims of the economic recession. In paid infomercials on BET, Popoff offers “supernatural debt relief” in exchange for offerings of hundreds or even thousands of dollars. This business is so lucrative that according to recent IRS documents, Popoff took in $23.5 million and paid himself and his immediate family more than $1 million in one year alone.
-
The Refusal to Face Reality Award goes to Andrew Wakefield, the researcher who launched the modern anti-vaccine panic with unfounded statements linking the MMR vaccine with autism that were not borne out by any research, even his own. In 2010, The Lancet retracted his paper on the MMR vaccine, and this year the British medical journal BMJ called Wakefield’s paper an outright fraud, finding “clear evidence of falsification of data” and that “he sought to exploit the ensuing MMR scare for financial gain,” taking more than $674,000 from lawyers who intended to sue vaccine manufacturers. Yet Wakefield continues to ask the public to believe he is the victim. In a recent article in NaturalNews, Wakefield called the American Academy of Pediatrics and The Lancet “instruments of a state that I don’t really want to be associated with.”
(via randi.org)
-
-
Power Balance scam
via revision3.comThis weeks episode of Scam School was a great one. Brian Brushwood shows how the Power Balance guys are scamming everybody out of their money for their stupid little bands. I don’t like how he pussy foots around by saying he isn’t sure how the real Power Balance bands work, when we all know they are a scam and work exactly the same as the Placebo Bands do. He was probably just covering his ass.
-
inFact: Vaccine Ingredients
-
Phil Plait – Don’t Be a Dick
I finally had time to watch Phil Plait’s “Don’t Be A Dick” talk. Like all of Phil Plait’s talks, this is a must view also. He explains how hard it is to changes people’s minds when they think they are right, and being a dick about it makes it that much harder.
One of my biggest pet peeves is people that believe in woo, or any other nonsense that is not based on facts. I try to be nice about it when I see it.
I gave up talking to my family about their woo beliefs. My Brother is a chiropractor, and the rest of my family is pretty religious. Their belief in nonsense runs rampant. I don’t want any family fights, so I just keep my mouth shut.
But online is a different story. I try to be nice and point people who believe in woo in the right direction. Whenever I see someone online afraid to vaccinate their kids because they are afraid of Autism, I try to point them to the REAL facts. Most of the time I just get blown off.
Often times I hear people talking about going to an acupuncturist, or taking some worthless supplement, or getting their ears cleaned out with ear candling — all nonsense.
It’s really had to get people to look at the REAL facts. It’s so easy for people to know what answers they want, and then find sites that confirm them. The internet is full of woo, and many of the woo sites come up high on Google because they all have some kind of product to sell you. Real facts are hard to find, and when you do they are a really dry read. The real trick is learning how to think critically, and use common sense.